Is San Mateo Safe? A Look at Crime & Neighborhoods

San Mateo, California, is a mid-sized city located on the Peninsula between the metropolitan hubs of San Francisco and San Jose. It is often perceived as a desirable residential location due to its suburban character and proximity to major Bay Area employment centers. San Mateo generally maintains a reputation for safety compared to its larger, more urban neighbors. Understanding the city’s safety profile requires a look into specific crime data and localized risks.

Understanding Crime Data

San Mateo’s violent crime rate, which includes offenses like robbery and assault, is notably lower than both the state and national averages. The city’s violent crime rate is approximately 2.3 incidents per 1,000 residents. This is significantly below the California average of 4.4 per 1,000 and the U.S. national average of 4.0 per 1,000 residents, based on recent projections.

The city’s property crime rate presents a more nuanced picture when analyzed against national and state figures. San Mateo’s property crime rate is estimated at around 19.8 incidents per 1,000 residents. While this is below California’s average of 24.2 per 1,000, it hovers close to the national average of 21.0 per 1,000 residents. The overall crime rate, which combines both violent and property incidents, suggests San Mateo is safer than many comparable cities nationwide.

Common Risks and Neighborhood Nuances

The most prevalent safety concern in San Mateo involves property crime, particularly theft from vehicles and package theft. Auto burglaries often manifest as “smash-and-grab” incidents, where criminals target vehicles with visible items like electronics or bags. These incidents frequently cluster in dense commercial parking areas, such as near shopping centers, and in residential parking lots where vehicles are left overnight.

Safety levels can vary noticeably across the city’s distinct neighborhoods. The central parts of San Mateo, which include the Downtown area and areas near major transit hubs like the Caltrain station, typically report higher concentrations of incidents due to increased foot traffic and commercial activity. In contrast, residential neighborhoods located further from the city center, such as Parkside, Sugarloaf West, and the Beresford Park area, generally maintain the lowest crime rates. Residents in these safer neighborhoods have a lower chance of becoming victims of crime, ranging from approximately 1 in 48 in the safest sectors.

Local Safety Resources

The San Mateo Police Department (SMPD) promotes a community-oriented approach to maintaining public safety. Residents can engage directly with law enforcement through programs designed to foster cooperation. The non-emergency dispatch line, 650-522-7700, serves as the primary point of contact for reporting non-urgent suspicious activity and minor crimes.

The city features one of the most active Neighborhood Watch programs in the county, relying on block captains to disseminate crime trends and safety alerts. Residents interested in starting or joining a group can contact the Neighborhood Watch Coordinator for resources and assistance. The SMPD also offers specialized initiatives. These include the Community Police Academy, an 11-week program providing citizens with insight into police operations, and the Police Activities League (PAL), which offers supervised activities for youth to build positive relationships with officers.